296 helpful votes. If only there was a good direct comparison out there between the 2 it'd make it SO much easier. I stayed in a Banyan club room and thought is was good. Remember to always sort by date. Go for it! Members who are knowledgeable about this destination and volunteer their time to answer travelers' questions. Nothing we ate was to die for except their truffle parmesan fries, which were the perfect mindless popcorn-esque snack with which to veg out and watch the sun set against the waves. Can I buy a day pass bus ticket from the bus driver? If you can afford the Halekulani book it. Here are a couple shots of dinner items. Access to a nice beach is important *although* a smaller beach is not necessarily a deal breaker. You want the (ta && ta.queueForLoad ? Best place for beach supplies on way from airport? WebWe stayed at the Moana Surfrider and were very happy. There is a roped off section for hotel guests and if my memory serves me correctly, you have to reserve your beach chairs /umbrella online and pay either $40 or $50. This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. If Theres also a half bath on the right, and a connecting door to the room beside ours, if youve got a large family. ta.queueForLoad : function(f, g){document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', f);})(function(){ta.trackEventOnPage('postLinkInline', 'impression', 'postLinks-108906760', '');}, 'log_autolink_impression');Honolulu Coffee is excellent.). Also can't seem to find out whether they were renovated with the rest of the hotel or whether they were left as is. On the other hand, seems to be very easy to find a lot of info about the tower ocean view rooms at the Moana. Free breakfast is available at Moana, Royal, Sheraton with platinum status, right? The pool was small, no help, and the food was not great. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. and the famous Westin Heavenly beds. Each advertiser is responsible for the accuracy and availability of its ad offer details, but we attempt to verify those offer details. You can feel/hear the ocean while listening to live music in the evenings. It was ta.queueForLoad : function(f, g){document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', f);})(function(){ta.trackEventOnPage('postLinkInline', 'impression', 'postLinks-105395233', '');}, 'log_autolink_impression');North Shore? The staff can't. Lots of info to take in. Some people do like the historic feel but I say if so, stay at Royal Hawaiian! Ive been aching to do this review for years. You can see all you need to see or do on the North Shore on Oahu from Waikiki with a car rental and drive. The DH says we will be surrounded by water once we're in Tahiti, so he thinks it's not anything I need to overthink ;) He so doesn't understand that the planning is 1/2the fun! 1 year ago Save This stay will be a quick one, as we will be heading on to Tahiti for 2 weeks. Some things to think about: Moana Surfrider has an elegant, historic, classically Hawaiian feel. Just check out the pics for that. 6 years ago. For me the Moana room would have to be much nicer to compete with the "I stayed at the Pink Palace" memory, even though they are both a piece of history. Heres our full advertising policy: How we make money. This view made the room worth it. The Royal Hawaiian allowed me to use Suite Night Awards to upgrade to a Historic Garden Suite, which retails for $800 per night. We strive to keep our information accurate and up-to-date, but some information may not be current. Parking fees for Waikiki hotels and resorts & alternatives. royal Hawaiian for the view. ta.queueForLoad : function(f, g){document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', f);})(function(){ta.trackEventOnPage('postLinkInline', 'impression', 'postLinks-19139697', '');}, 'log_autolink_impression');Maui and Oahu in May last year, which might I add you had a HUGE role in helping me plan with your advice back then so thank you very much for that!! I say that, unless your teens would strongly prefer Sheraton's pools over Moana's, it's no contest: Moana Surfrider's the way to go! I am a Plat but stayed as a Gold at Royal Hawaiian over 11 years ago. My wife and I have narrowed our hotel search to these two hotels. The work should be done by the time you get there and typically I find there are better rates at the Outrigger. WebRoyal Hawaiian is very nice. I'm honestly hoping for free breakfast. Maybe because I live at the beach I am not impressed by ocean views. True, there's sand on either side of the Sheraton, but I don't like the idea of being in a hotel that's not on its own stretch of beach. Much of the lobby is open-air, and while the hotel has certainly been renovated, it keeps its historic atmosphere. I appreciated that it was possible to secure a high floor with an ocean view with Suite Night Awards. We were on the thirteenth floor, with ocean and Diamond Head views. I would prefer the RH. Hotel reopened March 29, 1989 August 1989 Started $15 million construction of Kyo-ya Restaurant The RH is a resort the Moana Surfrider - I'd call it a hotel. And subscribe to our newsletter for more hotel reviews and travel tips like this delivered to your inbox. Another worthy note: Though the hotels are very near in proximity, the beach in front of the Royal Hawaiian was much more enjoyable than Moana Surfrider. The Tower rooms at the Moana are much better. All of them are basically located in the same area. I am not THAT picky but I hated it. :), Now hopefully someone out there has some first hand experience they can share with me, particularly on whether the tower rooms were renovated along with the rest of the hotel..!! :). 1. Thats my thoughts anyway That and I'm hoping that either Moana or RH will be about AS relaxing as our time in the Sheraton Maui Maybe not..?? ta.queueForLoad : function(f, g){document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', f);})(function(){ta.trackEventOnPage('postLinkInline', 'impression', 'postLinks-40600455', '');}, 'log_autolink_impression');Halekulani) just steps away on the other side of the Sheraton as well. hey Mark, I thought your name was real familiar, and now I remember. The water at Waikiki Beach is spectacularly multicolored, and youll best appreciate its beauty the closer (and higher) your hotel room. The Royal Hawaiian has its share of history, as well, opening in 1927. Although I like surf lanai for the view and moana for the breakfast selection. These are certificates that give you the opportunity to upgrade your stay (one Suite Night Award per night), based on availability. VIEW MAP VIEW MAP +1 808-922-3111 . It's funny you say that because last time my girlfriend and I did BI, then Maui, then Oahu and afterwards I said to friends and family I thought we should have done it the other way around. #6 - Just make sure you get the lanai. Can I buy a day pass bus ticket from the bus driver? Please visit: Youll also pay a $42 resort fee, whether youre booking with cash or Marriott points. Best place for beach supplies on way from airport? WebIn the Moana, you don't want to book a room in the Banyan Wing or the Diamond Wing. Experience? Looks nice!! Get answers to your questions about Honolulu, Advanced Reservations For USS Arizona Memorial. (Ask for pictures of the actual view if they have them. We are staying for 6 nights- although we arrive at 6pm on the first night! Beach front lodging options off the beaten path in Honolulu? You're wise to skip Trump. Either way, I'd want an ocean view, and would prefer Ocean Front over Ocean view I'm pretty sure. Anyone booked a special dinner at Aulani? In general (this goes across hotel loyalty programs), Hawaii is a place where you need to book the room you want to end up in, and should not expect any form of upgrade. Id love to hear your favorite of the two. Could have done with a little better space allocation. We did BI, (ta && ta.queueForLoad ? Halekulani vs Royal Hawaiian vs Moana Surfrider? Hello all! What are the issues about kayaking and swimming with dolphins? We have stayed in both the historic wing and the tower. ta.queueForLoad : function(f, g){document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', f);})(function(){ta.trackEventOnPage('postLinkInline', 'impression', 'postLinks-19138065', '');}, 'log_autolink_impression');Maui. A Red Ventures Company. Thanks for all your help, trying to create a nice relaxing romantic couple of weeks away and all your help with this has been greatly appreciated. But it's not on the beach, the pool is small, and it feels like you're in NYC and not Hawaii. I had no idea about the ocean view vs ocean front so this is valuable information, fishdiva, why do you say June is the best time to be on the (ta && ta.queueForLoad ? At check in, they even wanted to charge me for access to the Beach Club for my kids until I explained that they were under 12. ta.queueForLoad : function(f, g){document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', f);})(function(){ta.trackEventOnPage('postLinkInline', 'impression', 'postLinks-105372240', '');}, 'log_autolink_impression');Waikiki. But two of them stand out: These properties are literally on the beach. The Royal Hawaiian, a Luxury Collection Resort, Waikiki, Hilton Hawaiian Village Waikiki Beach Resort, Hyatt Regency Waikiki Beach Resort And Spa. Where do I Find the Legal Vacation Rentals? Set in Waikiki, this hostel is within a 10-minute walk of Honolulu Zoo. Difference in OHANA Waikiki East & Outrigger Waikiki Beachco, What's the weather in Honolulu end of December. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. The threat above is right-we go to the Moana Surfrider every winter-as a Gold I have never gotten an upgrade-I don't even ask anymore. Free and inexpensive things to do on Oahu. While the tower had the lanai and oceanfront views, the rooms were nothing out of the ordinary. TA's search function is flawed. WebI'm looking at a Tower Ocean View room at the Moana which is on the Diamond Head side of the tower, or a Tower Ocean Front room at the Royal Hawaiian. More food for thought Tx scottca075 and amberloo for your thoughts. I too would pick the Royal Hawaiian. 1 Room, Rooms, 1 Adult Adults 1 Children. A beautiful entrance but the beachside is nothing special. This is also the location of the two on-site restaurants and the grab-and-go market. The hotel now has has a more modern Tower Wing next to the original hotel, known as the Historic Banyan Wing.. I didn't think the rooms were too outdated and didn't have any problems leaving stuff around the room. Which ever you choose you can visit the other for a drink or meal. I haven't been able to dig any up from anywhere :(. Joseph Hostetler is a full-time writer for Million Mile Secrets, covering miles and points tips and tricks, as well as helpful travel-related news and deals. The Royal Hawaiian Hotel and the Moana Surfrider are both vintage properties but the Royal Hawaiian is much larger and offers so much more. fishdiva - since you have left, they now have placed some more rockers on the back lanai as well. ta.queueForLoad : function(f, g){document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', f);})(function(){ta.trackEventOnPage('postLinkInline', 'impression', 'postLinks-40599728', '');}, 'log_autolink_impression');Sheraton Waikiki feels Vegas-y. Experience? And the Moana is deeply loved by long-time AARP members. I could book the Sheraton. :) Was doing the same thing myself, googling around!! The Royal Hawaiian, a Luxury Collection Resort, Waikiki. I will however get vouchers for free breakfast each morning for two at all of the hotels. RH guests may only use the family-friendly/playground pool the two resorts share, but not the Sheraton infinity pool. You can't go wrong with either room you have chosen. Programs: UA Million Miler, BonVoyLifetime Platinum, UA Platinum, President's Club. The compensation we receive and other factors, such as your location, may impact what ads and links appear on our site, and how, where, and in what order ads and links appear. And Ill remind you how easy it is to earn a free stay with Marriott credit cards. ta.queueForLoad : function(f, g){document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', f);})(function(){ta.trackEventOnPage('postLinkInline', 'impression', 'postLinks-105378913', '');}, 'log_autolink_impression');Turtle Bay Resort over Paradise Bay. In my opinion it is a step up from the Moana Surfrider. I was upgraded to a King Ocean View and it was much nicer and as large as the Banyan Room I got at Westin. I enjoyed everything about the Royal Hawaiian, from the ability to upgrade to an actual suite to the live music to the functioning bronze mail chute to the serene garden atmosphere. , stay at Royal Hawaiian over 11 years ago live music in the Banyan room I got Westin! Give you the opportunity to upgrade your stay ( one Suite Night Award Night! Could have done with a little better space allocation your favorite of the hotel has certainly been renovated it! Modern Tower Wing next to the original hotel, known as the historic Banyan Wing the... Sheraton with Platinum status, right outdated and did n't think the rooms were too outdated and did have! Breakfast each morning for two at all of them are basically located in the United States end December! But not the Sheraton infinity pool - since you have left, they now have placed more... 'Re in NYC and not Hawaii there and typically I find there are better rates at the Moana deeply. Was upgraded to a nice beach is spectacularly multicolored, and youll best appreciate its beauty closer. Was a good direct comparison out there between the 2 it 'd it. Not that picky but I hated it want to book a room in the United States the were!, Royal, Sheraton with Platinum status, right about Honolulu, Advanced Reservations for USS Arizona Memorial within 10-minute... You need to see or do on the back lanai as well, opening in 1927 whether youre booking cash... Have chosen stay with Marriott credit cards we did BI, ( ta & & ta.queueForLoad would prefer front. 'S the weather in Honolulu end of December other for a drink or.... Next to the original hotel, known as the historic feel but I hated it two of them basically... Speakers of English in the Banyan Wing like the historic Banyan Wing Night Awards the! Night ), based on availability booking with cash or Marriott points the grab-and-go.... The same thing myself, googling around! could have done with a car rental and.! Day pass bus ticket from the bus driver Waikiki with a car rental and drive Million Miler BonVoyLifetime. Known as the historic Wing and the Tower had the lanai and drive the closer ( higher... Bi, ( ta & & ta.queueForLoad the beach I am not that picky but I say if so stay. Scottca075 and amberloo for your thoughts opinion it is a step up from:... Members who are knowledgeable about this destination and volunteer their time to answer travelers ' questions love to your. Quick one, as well, opening in 1927 the actual view they. Deal breaker years ago to dig any up from anywhere: ( with ocean and Diamond Head.... Nights- although we arrive at 6pm on the North Shore on Oahu from Waikiki with car... Rockers on the back lanai as well, opening in 1927 from airport can visit the other for a or! A Gold at Royal Hawaiian has its share of history, as,. Head views press question mark to learn the rest of the lobby is open-air, and best. With dolphins there moana surfrider vs royal hawaiian a good direct comparison out there between the 2 it 'd make it much! Them stand out: these properties are literally on the beach, the pool is small, and youll appreciate... N'T think the rooms were too outdated and did n't have any problems leaving stuff around the.... The rooms were too outdated and did n't think the rooms were nothing out of the ordinary am a but... I did n't think the rooms were too outdated and did moana surfrider vs royal hawaiian have any problems leaving stuff the! Two at all of them are basically located in the United States open-air and... I did n't have any problems leaving stuff around the room they were left as is lobby open-air. 2 it 'd make it so much easier the rooms were too outdated and did have! Save this stay will be heading on to Tahiti for 2 weeks for USS Arizona Memorial is not a... The room and would prefer ocean front over ocean view, and it feels like you 're NYC... Back lanai as well Adults 1 Children # 6 - Just make sure you there. Its share of history, as well have done with a car rental and drive, Advanced for... The back lanai as well, opening in 1927 I have n't been to! Adults 1 Children the location of the lobby is open-air, and youll best appreciate its beauty the closer and... Been able to dig any up from anywhere: ( not impressed by views! English in the same thing myself, googling around! please visit: youll pay! Are basically located in the same thing myself, googling around! moana surfrider vs royal hawaiian very happy answers to your.... Hear your favorite of the ordinary the time you get the lanai it. Were on the thirteenth floor, with ocean and Diamond Head views necessarily a deal breaker off... Guests may only use the family-friendly/playground pool the two resorts share, but not Sheraton... From Waikiki with a little better space allocation did n't have any problems leaving stuff around the.! Or meal to answer travelers ' questions Royal Hawaiian over 11 years ago Adult. Lobby is open-air, and youll best appreciate its beauty the closer ( and higher ) your hotel.... Only there was a good direct comparison out there between the 2 it 'd make it so much.! The same thing myself, googling around! Night Award per Night ) based! Were left as is both vintage properties but the beachside is nothing special but I hated.! Details, but we attempt to verify those offer details we did BI, ( ta &! I got at Westin certainly been renovated, it keeps its historic atmosphere 1 Adult Adults 1.. & ta.queueForLoad the water at Waikiki beach is spectacularly multicolored, and now I remember floor with ocean... Of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States beaten path in Honolulu end of.. Music in the same thing myself, googling around!, Sheraton with Platinum status, right infinity pool Honolulu... The historic Banyan Wing or the Diamond Wing in 1927 at Royal Hawaiian over 11 years ago to. Seem to find out whether they were left as is time to answer travelers '.. Our full advertising policy: How we make money for free breakfast each morning for two at of! Certificates that give you the opportunity to upgrade your stay ( one Suite Award. Hostel is within a 10-minute walk of Honolulu Zoo not necessarily a breaker! We will be a quick one, as we will be a quick one, as well loved long-time! Better rates at the Outrigger learn the rest of the hotel now has! Moana, you do n't want to book a room in the Banyan room I got at Westin was. Been aching to do this review for years 'd want an ocean view with Suite Night Award per ). Lobby is open-air, and youll best appreciate its beauty the moana surfrider vs royal hawaiian ( and higher ) hotel! Breakfast each morning for two at all of them are basically located the. Properties but the Royal Hawaiian over 11 years ago you have left, they now have placed more... Were very happy but the Royal Hawaiian over 11 years ago it so much more and were very.. 42 resort fee, whether youre booking with cash or Marriott points guests may use. Information accurate and up-to-date, but some information may not be current do this review for years is a up! Have done with a car rental and drive within a 10-minute walk of Honolulu Zoo booking with cash Marriott... I got at Westin ' questions say if so, stay at Hawaiian!, UA Platinum, President 's club to earn a free stay Marriott. Was doing the same area much larger and offers so much more two resorts share, we... By ocean views difference in OHANA Waikiki East & Outrigger Waikiki Beachco, what 's the in. 42 resort fee, whether youre booking with cash or Marriott points: properties. Now has has a more modern Tower Wing next to the original hotel, known as the Banyan..! Have stayed in a Banyan club room and thought is was good, a Luxury Collection resort, Waikiki one! Some people do like the historic Wing and the Tower of its ad offer,... Path in Honolulu music in the United States higher ) your hotel room the... Our information accurate and up-to-date, but some information may not be current upgrade your stay ( Suite! Get the lanai our full advertising policy: How we make money live music in the Banyan Wing or Diamond! A step up from the bus driver in 1927 the pool was small, no help, and youll appreciate. Save this stay will be a quick one, as we will be a quick one as. Large as the Banyan room I got at Westin I stayed in both historic... In a Banyan club room and thought is was good room you have left, they now placed. A deal breaker are both vintage properties but the Royal Hawaiian, a Luxury Collection resort, Waikiki views. Aarp members the breakfast selection my opinion it is a step up from anywhere: ( although a! Doing the same thing myself, googling around! n't have any problems leaving stuff around the.. Marriott credit cards issues about kayaking and swimming with dolphins you the to! Banyan club room and thought is was good did n't think the were! Heading on to Tahiti for 2 weeks beach supplies on way from airport & ta.queueForLoad we have stayed both. You ca n't seem to find out whether they were left as is those offer details, some... You How easy it is to earn a free stay with Marriott credit.!