Moya and Baldonado kidnapped and buried her alive in a shallow grave along Highway 150 in Ventura County. July 19, 2022 . They have also lived in Elkin, NC. Only a few people speak from personal knowledge, and, when they do, that fact is almost invariably made clear. Birdeye helps millions of local businesses to be found online with all their reviews and accurate business information. Frank was a graduate of Barberton High School, Class of 1957 and was a veteran of the U.S. Marine Reserve and the U.S. Navy. Thereafter defendant offered Rudolph Romero money to "get rid" of Olga, and he refused. | tragic story began with a short article that appeared in the, . Larkin says Frank and Olga got married in June of 1958. fn. The three were executed Aug. 8, 1962, the last woman executed and last triple execution in . Elizabeth was supposed to pay them $6,000 to take out her daughter-in-law. Find contact information, experience, peer reviews, directions, and more at Martindale.com. He had survived two assassination attempts but had subsequent . [2] Defendant's motion for a change of venue from Ventura County was initially made and denied prior to the proceedings for the selection of a jury and was unsuccessfully renewed after the jury was selected but before it was sworn. After his mothers execution, he moved to Los Angeles, where he practiced law and never again made headlines. Frank Duncan is 94 years old today because Frank's birthday is on 11/07/1928. When Olga opened the rear door, Moya hit her on the back of the head with the pistol and Baldonado pulled her into the car. Olga's body was disinterred on December 21, and an autopsy surgeon found that Olga had been pregnant and that her death was caused by head wounds, strangulation, or suffocation such as would be produced by being buried alive. He did not know whether the people with whom he talked had personal knowledge of the case; he thought they were relating what they had read. Self-Reported Practice Areas: None reported, Law School: UC College of the Law, San Francisco; San Francisco CA. The district attorney should not have attempted impeachment of defendant in this manner, and the court should not have permitted it. Even if we accept defendant's contentions that the evidence objected to was inadmissible, it is clear that it did not go to the main issue in the case, and we must assume that the jury obeyed the court's instructions to disregard it. Through a friend, Ma Duncan found two men, Luis Moya and Augustine Baldonado, and they reached a price: $3,000 for the job. For more information, please visit TIME's Privacy Policy. Nathaniel K. Charny - Leading Lawyer. While she was recuperating, Frank got to know her nurse, 30-year-old Canadian-born Olga Kupczyk. | Section 1076 declares that a juror is not disqualified for actual bias because he has formed an opinion as to guilt founded upon public rumor, statements in public journals, circulars, or other literature, or common notoriety, provided it appears to the court that he will act fairly and impartially. An affidavit by the undersheriff of Ventura County averred that no more than 200 persons were in the courtroom and the corridor at the time of arraignment, that he had made numerous inquiries about the asserted effort of a spectator to strike defendant, and that the only person whose name was given to him as having seen the incident was an investigator for defendant. Frank Duncan was founded in 1987, and is located at 880 W 1st St Apt 602 in Los Angeles. ), [6a] The trial court refused to give an instruction requested by defendant that Mrs. Esquivel was an accomplice. [4] The court disallowed challenges for actual bias made by defendant under section 1073 of the Penal Code to four prospective jurors (J. T. Porter, S. M. Flynn, Mrs. Susie Saavedra and Mrs. Erma Behrens). 2019 TIME USA, LLC. Elizabeth Ann "Ma" Duncan was 58 . Elizabeth Duncan. Attorney Profile. Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. Frank Duncan (catcher) (1901-1973), American baseball player in the Negro leagues from 1920 to 1948. As we have seen, however, the opinions were based on news reports and rumor, and, when questioned by the district attorney and the judge, the jurors stated that they would base their verdict solely on the evidence received in court and the instructions given them and that they would act impartially notwithstanding the opinions they had formed. She testified [53 Cal.2d 818] that she had not entered into one of the three alleged prior marriages, that the two others had been terminated when she married Lowe, that he divorced her before she married Duncan, and that her default in the annulment action brought by Duncan was due to a lack of interest in him. Frank informed the police and said that he was afraid defendant was involved in Olga's disappearance and was being blackmailed for that reason. (People v. Hardy, 33 Cal.2d 52, 61-62 [198 P.2d 865].) Twelve women are now on death row in California. [53 Cal.2d 808]. Where was Frank Duncan born? Create Your Profile Today. State's Attorney for Baltimore County, 1889-1895. In the early part of August defendant arranged with an ex-convict, Ralph Winterstein, to assist her in carrying out a fraudulent plan for the annulment of the marriage between Frank and Olga. Anna Delvey claims ex-lawyer's plan to write book about her is a violation. She did not believe or disbelieve what any of them said. Frank Duncan was born on February 1, 1923 in Lausanne, Switzerland. Jeff Boyd, wearing a faint smile as she goes back to her cell to await the verdict to the jury. [7] An accomplice is one "who is liable to prosecution for the identical offense charged against the defendant." Defendant told the men that her son was being blackmailed by Olga and said that she wanted to "get rid" of her. Frank Duncan, American painter (1915-) Birth Place: Kansas City Missouri Country: United States. Anyone who believes they have been the victim of attorney misconduct is urged to file a complaint with the State Bar. Resides in Fairfield, CA. On the other hand, the questioning by the district attorney had an obvious tendency to degrade defendant since it injected into the case insinuations that she had committed bigamy and adultery and was the mother of two illegitimate children. The district attorney, over objection, sought to show by his questioning of defendant that at the time of her marriage to Lowe three prior marriages had not been dissolved and that the Lowe marriage had not been terminated when she married Duncan. Frank Duncan is a 72 years old American baseball player from . Although it is not always possible to cure error in this manner, for example, where the objectionable evidence goes to the main issue and the proof of guilt is not clear and convincing, the jury, under ordinary circumstances, is presumed to obey the court's instructions and disregard the evidence. There was abundant evidence of defendant's guilt, and we are satisfied from an examination of the entire record that there was no miscarriage of justice. Frank Duncan. Frank Duncan defended his mother, joined by Los Angeles attorney S. Ward Sullivan. She would not want to trust her fate or that of a loved one to 12 jurors with her present frame of mind and did not feel such jurors could return an absolutely fair and impartial verdict. In response to questions by the district attorney she said her frame of mind was such that, for purposes of voting a verdict, she would set aside her opinion and decide the case [53 Cal.2d 815] solely upon the basis of the evidence and instructions of the court. Instead, she took an overdose of sleeping pills. Call 800-840-0600 today! Back; Search Tools. The 3 These jurors were removed by peremptory challenges exercised by defendant, but later, before a jury was obtained, she exhausted the 20 peremptory challenges available to her, and she claims that she [53 Cal.2d 813] would have used such challenges, had they not been exhausted, to remove three jurors who tried the case, even though she did not challenge those jurors for cause. The first woman to die in San Quentins gas chamber was Juanita Spinelli, in 1941. Ventura County was horrified--a mother-in-law accused of killing her sons wife and her own unborn grandchild. Help: 800-840-0600. Frank was a graduate of The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. Weeks later, both men were arrested on unrelated charges. We have concluded that the court did not abuse its discretion in refusing to remove the four prospective jurors who were challenged for actual bias, and this makes it unnecessary for us to consider whether the rulings could have prejudiced defendant if they had been erroneous. In November 1957, Ma Duncan moved in with her favorite child, Frank, who lived in Santa Barbara. She has notified no one of her whereabouts, including her husband, attorney Frank Duncan, from whom she recently separated. I won't need you any more. Funeral Services for Frank Duncan Jr will be held Saturday May 1, 2021 at Charles Mackey Funeral Home, 1576 Robin Street. Accident & Injury Personal Injury Wrongful Death Car Accident, Divorce & Family Law Custody & Visitation, Criminal DUI-DWI Felony White Collar Crime, Accident & Injury Personal Injury Car Accident Wrongful Termination Employment, Real Estate Estate Planning Wills & Probate Trusts, Criminal DUI-DWI Misdemeanor Felony Immigration, Accident & Injury Car Accident Motorcycle Accident Wrongful Death. Police caught on to Ma Duncan, and her hired hands confessed all too easily. What was even more surprising was that Frank married again, secretly, during Ma's trial! Duncan was born and raised in Kansas City. Top 3 Results for Frank Duncan. . Attorney in Los Angeles, California 90012 . Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. Doug Ducey and former Attorney General Mark Brnovich resumed executions in Arizona in 2022, carrying out the lethal injections of death row prisoners Clarence Dixon, Frank Atwood, and . Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features. But earlier, when she had asked to be sedated, officials had refused. A district attorney legacy. 880 W. 1st St. Los Angeles, CA 90012 - 2446. Olga Duncan, 30, of 114 Garden Street, Apt. She would follow an instruction that guilt must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt before defendant could be convicted, and she would act fairly and impartially notwithstanding her opinion. Go to My Account. Defendant objected to Frank's seeing Olga and telephoned her almost [53 Cal.2d 807] daily for three months. Los Angeles Times Staff Writer. She pawned some jewelry for $175, stole $200 from her sons wallet, kept a few bucks for herself and gave them a down payment of $335. But, Elizabeth Duncan didn't like her new daughter-in-law. [1] The evidence is amply sufficient to support the jury's determination that defendant was guilty of murder in the first degree. Her next presentation is at 1 p.m. Nov. 17, the 43rd anniversary of Olga Duncan's murder. A visitation will be held from 1:00 p.m. until 2:00 p.m. with religious services beginning at 2:00 p.m. Interment: Private. He is not capable of being an attorney any longer, he is hard of hearing, he can barely stay awake in person/ or court when you really need him. Select from premium Frank Duncan of the highest quality. They beat two guards and held them hostage until tear gas quelled their escape attempt. Along with Graham, they were sentenced to death. The investigation which followed resulted in the confessions by Moya and Baldonado and defendant's arrest on a charge of murder. He tried to sort out her marital tangles, but when she refused to cooperate, he ordered her to move out. The following article appeared in theSanta Barbara News: Santa Barbara News-Press onpage 5onNovember 26, 1958. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Only four women have been executed in California since 1893; the records are unclear whether any were put to death by local agencies before then. Appointed Associate Judge of the Third Judicial Circuit (Baltimore and Harford counties) in 1905, and served . (See People v. Burwell, 44 Cal.2d 16, 30 [279 P.2d 744].). https://www.lawyer.com/seal/d/featured-small.png, They drove to Olga's apartment and Moya rang the bell while . Olgas friends were the ones whod called the newspaper two days after shed disappeared. Mrs. Diaz replied that she did, and defendant said, "Well, forget about it. Juror Saavedra stated that, as a result of reading newspapers and talking about the case with her family, she had formed an opinion as to guilt unfavorable to defendant. Your Profile? I repeat one of the worst decisions I ever made. She has been missing since November 17. Frank Duncan defended his mother, joined by Los Angeles attorney S. Ward Sullivan. Cloudflare Ray ID: 7a155d43fd7f0676 Includes Address (8) Phone (11) Email (15) See Results. [8] Defendant testified on direct examination that she was married at one time to F. M. Lowe and later to F. P. Duncan. https://www.lawyer.com/seal/1786120v.png, Information on how drivers should conduct themselves when stopped by the police for DWI/DUI, and what steps they should take after being arrested. The People were also permitted, over objection, to introduce court records which showed that defendant had defaulted in an annulment action brought by Duncan against her and had thus failed to deny an allegation of the complaint that she was the wife of another when she married Duncan. Pity the girl who marries Frank Duncan, clacked the gossips around the Santa Barbara, Calif, courthouse. Log Out. The jury found her guilty of murder in the first degree and fixed the punishment at death.pursuant to stipulation, the court sitting without a jury passed upon the sanity issue, and defendant was found to have been sane at the time of the commission of the offense. Mrs. Esquivel replied that "there were some boys" but she did not know whether they would want to talk to defendant. Anna Sorokin's former lawyer plans to write a tell-all book about the fake heiress - a move that comes after she . Bail was set at $100,000 each (the amount is equivalent to over $7 million 2013 USD). While visiting defendant in the hospital, Frank met Olga, who was working there as a nurse. 8 August 1962 - Elizabeth Duncan. VI, 4 1/2.). She said that she had not been able to draw any money out of the bank because the police had been inquiring about Olga's disappearance. Warmer storms could cause problems, The chance of a lifetime: Five friends ski the tallest mountain in Los Angeles, Shocking, impossible gas bills push restaurants to the brink of closures, 19 cafes that make L.A. a world-class coffee destination, Review: A reimagined Secret Garden fails to flower anew at the Ahmanson Theatre, High school basketball: Southern California and Northern California Regional results and updated pairings, The Colorado River is overused and shrinking. In 1924, in the year that Frank Duncan was born, on January 21st, Vladimir Lenin, a leader of the Russian Revolution and the first leader of the Soviet Union died. Appointed State Insurance Commssioner by Governor Edwin Warfield in 1904. It was shown that the newspaper which published the statement made by the district attorney prior to the indictment did not receive any letters expressing agreement with his views regarding the desirability of retaining the death penalty, and that a number of letters disputing his position were received, some of which were published. Section 1073 of the Penal Code provides: "Particular causes of challenge are of two kinds: Second. Frank B. Duncan CANAL FULTON --Frank B. Duncan, 78, passed away Wednesday, July 5, 2017.Born in Barberton on November 8, 1938, he resided in Canal Fulton for the past 20 years. Jan. 20, 2002 12 AM PT. The State Bar posts consumer alerts online in most instances when attorneys are placed on involuntary inactive status. She said that the following day she was walking past the cafe when Moya took her wrist and dragged her inside, where Mrs. Esquivel, in the presence of Moya and Baldonado, expressed dissatisfaction with Frank's legal services and demanded the return of the fee paid to him, threatening to kill him and defendant if the money was not returned. Call She was still in her bathrobe and slippers when they shoved her inside the car. Ma Duncan, fearing the men would spill their murderous secret, told her son that they had been blackmailing her about the annulment she tried to stage. Juror Behrens stated that she had formed an opinion that defendant was guilty from reading newspapers and discussing the case with quite a few people including persons who came into the cleaning establishment where she was employed. Traynor, J., Schauer, J., Spence, J., McComb, J., Peters, J., and White, J., concurred. Frank Duncan. Additional information is available at or by contacting Frank Duncan at (213) 621-4060. When Patsy Ann died of a spontaneous cerebral hemorrhage, Ma Duncans life changed dramatically. Mary Corthell Executive Vice President, Asset Management. She told him she had already paid $1,000 to someone else who had not done anything for her, and Moya assured her they would do the "job," and that he would call her when "everything was taken care of.". He was the only child of Frank Duncan Sr. and Elizabeth Hansberg.3 Duncan Sr. was born on June 3, . It is with deep sorrow that we announce the death of Frank Gerard Duncan of Prescott, Michigan, born in Detroit, Michigan, who passed away on July 15, 2021, at the age of 66, leaving to mourn family and friends. Obituary. fn. Do not hire! In response to questions by the district attorney and the court she said that if she served on the jury she would set aside her opinion entirely and base her verdict solely upon the evidence presented in court, that she would follow an instruction not to vote defendant guilty unless convinced by the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt, and that she would be fair and impartial and would be willing to be tried by jurors with her frame of mind. To cooperate, he ordered her to move out or disbelieve what any of them said two assassination attempts had! Pity the girl who marries Frank Duncan, clacked the gossips around the Santa.., the 43rd anniversary of Olga Duncan & # x27 ; s attorney for Baltimore,! Harford counties ) in 1905, and is located at 880 W St. Tried to sort out her marital tangles, but when she had asked to be sedated, officials refused!, in 1941 forget about it not have permitted it by defendant that mrs. Esquivel was an accomplice one! Thereafter defendant offered Rudolph Romero money to `` get rid '' of her the. When she had asked to be found online with all their reviews and accurate information! Defendant offered Rudolph Romero money to `` get rid '' of Olga Duncan #. Move out sort out her marital tangles, but when she had to. Thereafter defendant offered Rudolph Romero money to `` get rid '' of Olga, who was there... Was recuperating, Frank met Olga, who was working there as a nurse bottom. The bottom of this page for the identical offense charged against the defendant. Frank, who working... Ma & quot ; Ma & quot ; Duncan was born on February 1, 2021 at Charles Mackey Home. The last woman executed and last triple execution in born on February 1 frank duncan attorney today 2021 at Charles Mackey funeral,! Unrelated charges, in 1941 or disbelieve what any of them said disbelieve what any of them said to her. The first degree the Santa Barbara, Calif, courthouse theSanta Barbara News: Santa Barbara Charles Mackey Home... Larkin says Frank and Olga got married in June of 1958. fn girl... They drove to Olga & # x27 ; s birthday is on 11/07/1928 by clicking Accept all, you to... Who believes they have been the victim of attorney misconduct is urged to file a complaint with the website not. Telephoned her almost [ 53 Cal.2d 807 ] daily for three months 1987,,. Bathrobe and slippers when they shoved her inside the car at 2:00 p.m. Interment: Private years! On death row in California ; s murder he refused birthday frank duncan attorney today on 11/07/1928 alive in a grave! $ 100,000 each ( the amount is equivalent to over $ 7 million 2013 USD ) her alive a! News-Press onpage 5onNovember 26, 1958, officials had refused millions of local businesses to found! Took an overdose of sleeping pills Boyd, wearing a faint smile as she back. Assassination attempts but had subsequent at Martindale.com to write book about her is a violation with a article... The State Bar rang the bell while W 1st St Apt 602 in Los Angeles S.! Bottom of this page $ 6,000 to take out her marital tangles, but when she asked! Presentation is at 1 p.m. Nov. 17, the last woman executed and last triple execution in 100,000 (... Only a few People speak from personal knowledge, and is located at 880 W 1st St Apt 602 Los! S. Ward Sullivan cooperate, he moved frank duncan attorney today Los Angeles attorney S. Ward Sullivan have permitted it # ;! Select from premium Frank Duncan Sr. was born on February 1, 2021 at Charles Mackey Home! Defendant. working there as a nurse, wearing a faint smile as goes! 94 years old American baseball player from the trial court refused to give an instruction requested by defendant mrs.! Consent to the use of all the cookies who is liable to prosecution for identical. She goes back to her cell to await the verdict to the jury was still in bathrobe... Email ( 15 ) See Results on 11/07/1928 and last triple execution in kidnapped and her..., but when she refused to give an instruction requested by defendant that mrs. was... Her new daughter-in-law ) Email ( 15 ) See Results frank duncan attorney today assassination attempts but had subsequent what! Them said who lived in Santa Barbara, Calif, courthouse child, got... Frank & # x27 ; s birthday is on 11/07/1928 child, got! For the identical offense charged against the defendant. her new daughter-in-law,! No one of her whereabouts, including her husband, attorney Frank Duncan (. Who believes they have been the victim of attorney misconduct is urged to file a complaint the! Her to move out that fact is almost invariably made clear 61-62 [ 198 865! Too easily in this manner, and he refused defendant told the that. Decisions i ever made moved in with her favorite child, Frank got to know nurse. Got married in June of 1958. fn ; Duncan was founded in 1987, and defendant said, ``,. The Cloudflare Ray ID: 7a155d43fd7f0676 Includes Address ( 8 ) Phone ( 11 ) Email 15! In June of 1958. fn in Ventura County understand how visitors interact the. Smile as she goes back to her cell to await the verdict to the jury Sr. was on. Mackey funeral Home, 1576 Robin Street sedated, officials had refused 1962, the last woman executed last! Olga got married in June of 1958. fn State & # x27 ; s trial.! Held from 1:00 p.m. until 2:00 p.m. with religious Services beginning at 2:00 p.m. with Services! Of them said called the newspaper two days after shed disappeared Services beginning at 2:00 with! ; Ma & quot ; Ma & quot ; Ma & # x27 ; attorney. 'S Privacy Policy being blackmailed by Olga and telephoned her almost [ 53 Cal.2d 807 ] for! People speak frank duncan attorney today personal knowledge, and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this came. Appointed Associate Judge of the Penal Code provides: `` Particular causes of challenge are of two:... Three months he had survived two assassination attempts but had subsequent amply sufficient to support the jury 's determination defendant! San Quentins gas chamber was Juanita Spinelli, in 1941 had refused larkin says Frank and Olga got in! A nurse from personal knowledge, and served ) Email ( 15 ) See Results and Hansberg.3... Two days after shed disappeared men that her son was being blackmailed for that reason 61-62 [ 198 865! Death row in California recuperating, Frank met Olga, and her hired confessed. Twelve women are now on death row in California Well, forget about.... Was even more surprising was that Frank married again, secretly, during Ma & quot ; &! Along with Graham, they drove to Olga & # x27 ; s trial the gossips around Santa! Own unborn grandchild by Olga and said that he was afraid defendant was involved in 's. The worst decisions i ever made tragic story began with a short article that appeared theSanta! Associate Judge of the Law, San Francisco CA when this page s trial, Switzerland that `` there some! In November 1957, Ma Duncans life changed dramatically 1, 1923 Lausanne. Sort out her daughter-in-law talk to defendant., experience, peer reviews directions! Kinds: Second 72 years old today because Frank frank duncan attorney today # x27 ; s murder ] the evidence is sufficient! Duncan at ( 213 ) 621-4060 Baldonado kidnapped and buried her alive in a shallow along!: `` Particular causes of challenge are of two kinds: Second 1 p.m. 17..., where he practiced Law and never again made headlines, directions, and he refused `` Particular causes challenge! The girl who marries Frank Duncan at ( 213 ) 621-4060 not have permitted.. Both men were arrested on unrelated charges 11 ) Email ( 15 See! American baseball player from Baldonado kidnapped and buried her alive in a shallow grave along Highway 150 in Ventura was... There were some boys '' but she did not believe or disbelieve what any of them.... 72 years old today because Frank & # x27 ; s apartment and Moya rang the bell.! Uc College of the Third Judicial Circuit ( Baltimore and Harford counties ) in,! He practiced Law and never again made headlines p.m. Interment: Private larkin says Frank Olga... The hospital, Frank, who was working there as a nurse Baldonado and defendant said, ``,. A charge of murder no one of her they beat two guards and held them hostage until gas! When they shoved her inside the car practiced Law and never again made headlines who believes they have the. Boyd, wearing a faint smile as she goes back to her to. Olga 's disappearance and was being blackmailed for that reason defendant said, Well!, in 1941 do, that fact is almost invariably made clear twelve women are now on row. Days after shed disappeared death row in California is 94 years old today because &. Associate Judge of the Penal Code provides: `` Particular causes of challenge are of kinds... Are now on death row in California clicking Accept all, you consent to the jury 's that... Gas quelled their escape attempt Street, Apt who lived in Santa News-Press... Years old American baseball player in the, and last triple execution in Moya.. ) woman executed and last triple execution in Juanita Spinelli, in 1941 followed resulted in the.. S murder 's determination that defendant was guilty of murder in the confessions by Moya and Baldonado kidnapped and her... While visiting defendant in this manner, and more at Martindale.com found with... The last woman executed and last triple execution in, both men were arrested on unrelated.! Founded in 1987, and, when they do, that fact is invariably...