I didn't see any violence. The technicians recovered three samples of so-called touch DNA - as few as seven or eight cells of skin that can be analysed with modern laboratory techniques. "He was very charming he was really fun to talk to. Marc O'Leary: I just need to talk to an attorney. The woman gave an interview to NPR's "This American Life.". Everything that she told us was the absolute truth," Cohnheim said. After a pause, Marc O'Leary opened the door. She doubted herself, wondering if there was something in her that needed to be fixed. Boston New York City Houston Chicago Los Angeles . "Then, he straddled her, made her go face down. He was sentenced to 327 and a half years in prison. And she would have to pay $500 (320) to cover the court's costs. "I wondered if they were victims of sexual assault, if they were even alive anymore," said Galbraith. "have actual photographs -- as disgusting as they were, of the actual rapes ended any speculation as to whether we had the right guy," said Prosecutor Weiner. However she was able to actually lift up, turn around, and face the man. Visit the Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network website or contact RAINN's National Helpline at 1-800-656-HOPE (4673). And after: Adult caregivers and professionals coming in and then out of her life, some distressing or abusive experiences, and a general lack of permanency. "He's only behind bars because of the work that you did together," Maher pointed out. Hendershot discovered the Lakewood patrol car had snapped its picture as O'Leary was headed to a branch of the Colorado Department of Motor Vehicles. The case also formed the basis for a book, A False Report: A True Story of Rape in America published in 2018, and was explored in an episode of the This American Life podcast. When they finished, the agents raced in. At the age of five, O'Leary developed a desire to hurt women after seeing a captured Princess Leia in "Return of the Jedi." I knew she had an alarm system, but she never used it. Detective Stacy Galbraith (the basis for Unbelievable's Karen Duvall, played by Merritt Wever) was the lead detective investigating another rape, this time in Colorado. It was hard for Amy to believe. Westminster detective Edna Hendershot had settled into her morning with her Starbucks usual: a venti, upside-down, skinny caramel macchiato. people search. He developed a pattern of spying on homes, both from the outside and from the inside after breaking in. The three then went to the police station so Marie could recant her recantation - that is, tell detectives that she had been telling the truth the first time. Just after noon, the agents saw a woman and a man who looked like O'Leary leave. "she says that she thought that she may have dreamed that this occurred. This dental device was sold to fix patients' jaws. The eight-part limited series dramatises this true story as well as the wider case that surrounded it, and is based on the award-winning article from The Marshall Project (which shines a light on the criminal justice system in the US) and Pro Publica (a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of power). They knew they finally had the right O'Leary in custody. was always the same. The detectives elevated "minor inconsistencies" - common among victims - into discrepancies, while ignoring strong evidence the crime had occurred. The photo showed a 6ft 1in man with hazel eyes. I was kinda scared maybe he could be in law enforcement," Galbraith replied. ". When he was done, he went about carefully cleaning anything that could have any trace of his DNA, stripping bed sheets and removing her clothes from the scene. The show made a pretty big deal about McCarthy (Marc O'Leary) having an encrypted hard drive so I'm wondering if that part was fiction. O'Leary was caught thanks to dogged work by two female detectives from different Colorado police forces combining their investigations. The extremely disturbing case is now the subject of a Netflix true-crime drama called Unbeliveable. Rittgarn asked. "Where do you go when you're five and already thinking about handcuffs?" Guess what, I got a picture of her after she's assaulted from the actual rapist,'" Maher asked. Marie wrote that the attacker said she could untie herself once he was gone: After he left I grabbed my phone (which was right next to my head) with my mouth and I tried to call Jordan back. O'Leary at the helm when boat collided with another vessel on Aug. 24, 2019. He tied her hands with a ribbon. What turned me on is fear. After comparing notes and getting to work, it soon became quite clear that they had a serial rapist on their hands. Currently, Marc O'Leary works as a Data Protection Officer at Strawberry Hill Povitica. Had her roll over. Marie told police she had been talking on the phone with her friend Jordan. O'Leary wasn't willing to discuss anything that he had not pleaded guilty to. This is something she later regretted. Marc O'Leary seemed strangely amused by the circumstances, and he would not cooperate. Over the next four hours, he raped her repeatedly. In the predawn hours, a white Mazda pickup truck appeared ten times. Each ring of the phone seemed to announce another friendship lost. It was a small, single-storey home in a run-down neighbourhood. "A white male -- about 6'2", 180," said Galbraith. And at Hendershot's crime scene in Westminster, there was another piece of evidence. Whatever he told me to do, I did it," she said. It had cost her sense of worth. She apologised - and agreed to write another statement, leaving no doubt it was a lie. "I said, 'Turn around, put your hands behind your back, you're under arrest,'" said Galbraith. As he grew older, he began to break into people's homes. It's an absolute nightmare. It was a young woman - far younger than the Colorado victims. She asked that her current location not be disclosed. I actually haven't seen these things beyond pictures," she said. "I saw him out there. She had been charged with filing a false report, which is why she was here today, to accept or turn down a plea deal. Two years later and 25 miles away, Golden, Colorado, police detective Stacy Galbraith was just starting her shift when a call came in. At 6 o'clock that Sunday morning, the team knocked on the O'Learys door, guns drawn, and Detective Galbraith found herself face to face with Marc O'Leary. Grusing saw that monster up close. He documented the assault with a digital camera and threatened to post the pictures online if she contacted the police. "I think everything was on the table at that point in time," said Hendershot. It took the entire group.". She was an 18-year-old woman, whose identity we are not revealing, living just outside Seattle in Lynnwood, Washington. According to The Marshall Project/Pro Publica's investigative article, there were protocols and guidelines available to the police that described some of the possible challenges of investigating rape, but the department did not have a dedicated sex-crimes unit. He had a term for what he was about to do: "rape theatre". "I definitely felt like we were up against the clock. Maher asked. Is he gone? The show and a few sources claim there's a 75gb encrypted hard drive of information. After Marc has been arrested the police find a 75gb hard drive that is password protected and Marc refused to reveal the password. Since the two rapes were not linked, O'Leary wasn't discovered as someone who should be further investigated. His brother, Michael O'Leary, had just left to get lunch with his girlfriend. Marie was Peggy's first foster child. By late January, the detectives decided they needed to broaden their scope. "I suppose because I wasn't looking for that, it just never occurred to me that it could happen.". Marc O'Leary, suspected of stalking and attacking so many women, was about to become hunted himself. it was like I'd just eaten Thanksgiving dinner. We earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article. Digital Spy participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites. He said he could come and pick her up, to take her to the police station. Bet you wish you could have shot me. You're this close to this guy," Maher asked Galbraith. Produced by Chris O'Connell, Lauren Clark and Lindsey Schwartz [This story first aired on Nov. 19, 2016.] So, too, did O'Leary's truck. Those victims were raped in Colorado towns Golden, Westminster, and Aurora. O'Leary also tied her wrists with her own shoelaces, gagged her, and blindfolded her. Just inside O'Leary's front door, they found a pair of gloves with that distinct honeycomb pattern. At 8.15am, Detective Galbraith knocked on the O'Learys' door. Marc O'Leary was a serial rapist across Colorado and Washington from 2008 to 2011. "But I didn't show him fear in any real way, and he knew I wasn't scared. Peggy, too, was mystified by Marie's demeanour. Rape Crisis England and Wales works towards the elimination of all forms of sexual violence and sexual misconduct. Turn away, he told Marie - and she did. "And what he picked up on was that they were made to shower for a certain time period and basically wash away the evidence.". The trailer is on YouTube. "It sounds to me like maybe he's protecting somebody else if he's willing to fess up to everything that he's done, but he's not willing to turn over all of the information that he has," she said. O'Leary pleaded guilty to 28 counts of rape. He wore a black mask. "And he just turned around, went down the stairs -- went out to the back, climbed over the fence, and left.". The trail is open year-round and is . This time, though, there was something different. Right? Shannon, an estate agent, and Marie were both "kind of goofy", Shannon says. "I'd walked up through this driveway. Maybe she was making up the rape to get moved to a new one. The story is dramatized in the 2019 Netflix series "Unbelievable." "He said that he would be willing to answer questions. "Absolutely, there's more," said Hendershot. "And ultimately, she was given a citation for false reporting.". They grabbed the drinking cups from the table. "He had real baggy pants on, so I lifted each pant leg up. Maybe it was the attacker waiting for the woman to fall asleep? After looking through the images, she found an answer. She was quiet at first. Galbraith immediately headed to the scene and spoke to the victim -- a 29 year-old woman who said she was in bed when she was attacked. Owner. "And he immediately just kinda looked at me and said, 'You know, I think we've had that here recently,'" she said. Please enter valid email address to continue. "He just went pale. Hendershot seized on them. But during the investigation, they began to doubt the young woman's truthfulness. "So not quite a fingerprint," Maher noted. It didn't sound real to me It sounded like a lot of drama, too, in some ways.". "She also described him as a little bit chubby," Galbraith added. We-- we got him.' "There were so many victims. Galbraith felt sick. That's what he said, 'We got him,'" she said. That's not accurate. Roll over onto your stomach, he told her. One who travelled, had a repetitive MO and was frustratingly careful when it came to leaving DNA evidence behind. "It was like, I felt like she was telling me the script of a Law & Order story.". "The patrol was being dispatched to a sexual assault that had just occurred," Det. Two police officers at different Colorado precincts combined their findings, including DNA evidence, leadingthem toone perpetrator. "And so it became important at that point in time to start conducting surveillance on him -- attempt to get the DNA from this individual," Hendershot explained. Kevin O'Leary's last-minute 'confession' made the Crown case at his wife's trial, prosecutor says At closing remarks Friday, defence lawyer Brian Greenspan meanwhile accused the Crown of . Generally considered a moderately challenging route, it takes an average of 4 h 15 min to complete. But Marie wanted to set out on her own. I can only hope that, you know, that my sentence today will satisfy them. And I said, 'What the f--k are you doing here Get outta here. In all the cases, the rapist told his victims he'd been stalking them for months -- watching their every move and breaking into their homes during test runs. Grown the Dust Bowl 100 from a 40-participant inaugural event in 2020 to an 800-participant, nationally recognized event . Did you want to just get in your car, go over, bang on the door and take him right then?" But what happened to that woman was far worse than the detectives could imagine. Neither had known Marie to be a liar - to exaggerate, sure, to want attention - but now, both knew they weren't alone in wondering if Marie had made this up. He tied her hands loosely behind her. Honeycomb marks. They even had a rape report from 2008, only they believed it was a false report. The report detailed how a 46-year-old artist had been accosted in her home by a man with a knife. On her way, she crossed a bridge. Gilraith and Hendershot spent thousands of hours poring over the evidence and picking apart their victims' statements to see how the cases were linked until they finally landed on a likely suspect:. As for threatening jail and a possible withdrawal of housing assistance, "These statements are coercive, cruel and unbelievably unprofessional," Rinta wrote. In an interview with police after his conviction, O'Leary recounted his attacks in detail. There was one lead. And he seemed to like that," said Grusing. Maher asked Galbraith. DMV records showed O'Leary sat for a driver's licence mugshot about four hours after the Westminster attack. "48 Hours" correspondent Maureen Maher asked Mary. "Specifically, each piece of evidence from one of the other assaults had a connection to the Lakewood case. It was tofu to somebody who wanted steak.". The attacker had left behind the tiniest traces of himself. The police questioned her repeatedly and started poking at inconsistencies in her story, once again highlighting that the justice system isn't necessarily set up to accommodate those that have experienced trauma. She joined forces with Detective Edna Hendershot of the Westminster Police Department (Grace Rasmussen in the Netflix series, played by Toni Collette) after finding out, by chance, that they were each working cases that shared similar details. "And I still remember this moment -- that's when he leaned back and smiled," said Grusing. Both had smudges on the back in the same place. She had responded to a report of a rape at an apartment complex in the northwest of her city. 2016 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. The dark mark on his leg. Detective Galbraith couldn't believe what she was reading. But in all of that evidence, there was nothing to link Marc O'Leary's brother, Michael, to any of the attacks. Moreover, Marie grew up to have a wonderful life and has a family of her own. I mean, I wanna think that people are good And so, I don't look for bad things," Pech told Maher. "He was lining her up for an assault," said Grusing. "He had kind of some bookshelves And he had it just kind of propped up on a shelf.". In January 2011, rapist Marc O'Leary was apprehended, and the head of the criminal-investigations division showed up at Adler's door to tell her that her photo had been found among his. "He was counting on the fact that we wouldn't talk to one another, that we wouldn't reach out, that we wouldn't communicate. Marie's treatment was found to be "coercive" and "cruel", according to the An Unbelievable Story of Rape article. That -- for that truck to be in that neighborhood in Lakewood, and also be in mine? They were a perfect match to those shoeprints found near two of the crime scenes. Marie's experience was the latest in a string of past abuses. Luckily, this means that the rapist (Marc O'Leary, in real life) was convicted to life in prison for 327 and a half years. We use your sign-up to provide content in the ways you've consented to and improve our understanding of you. Marie had made it through. Self-esteem gave way to self-loathing. The full version of this article was originally co-published by ProPublica and the Marshall Project. He would break into his victim's homes at night with his 'rape kit' and assault them repeatedly for. We talked. And he said, 'It's been all over the news he's committed a series of rapes,'" she said. The trail started in Aurora, east of Denver, on October 4, 2009, with the 65-year-old woman. An old school friend called to ask, "How could you lie about something like that?" Before the interview ended, he had a special message for Detective Galbraith: O'Leary to Grusing: Hi Stacy Galbraith. The subject line was pleading: "Sex Aslt Similars?" "We were thinking potentially military he knew what he was doing. But which one? Prosecutors charged him with with 28 counts ranging from sex assault to kidnapping and. Unexpectedly, a man came to the door. Energy stocks are gold in the market, according to "Shark Tank" investor Kevin O'Leary. "Did you know that at one point he was in the house and you were asleep?" It was an open-and-shut case. In Sergeant Mason's experience, when someone asked if they were in trouble, almost always they were. But the victim did remember that the attacker was white and blond, because she could see the hair on his arms. "And there's no fear in your life now associated with it?" Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. A woman, who we will call Mary, had no idea she was being stalked by a strange man. Then he walked to the bedroom. Snow covered the ground in patches. Both vehicles had tow balls on the back. He may have hidden the password if he was a serial killer (Colorado was a death penalty state but more on that later) or to prevent it from . Marc O'Leary to Grusing: And Julie Pech One night she left one of the windows open, so I climbed in she was asleep in the bedroom. What's more, Detective Hendershot was able to link the rape of 65-year-old Mary, in Aurora, to the same attacker. I won't let him instill fear in me. "I pulled out the flyer that I had ready," Grusing said. When questioned, Marie's account of the rape had some details that didn't completely add up. "Because there was no consistency," Maher noted. "and it came back as an Adidas," Det. He found a folder called "Girls" - and pictures that O'Leary had taken of his victims. Galbraith said. As far as I can find it's still uncracked. "I just screamed and he just told -- kept telling me to shut up." "She was isolated. "There was just no emotion. In her case, it was because of the trauma brought on by the rape. They discovered a pair of Under Armour gloves with a honeycomb pattern. Sergeant Jeffrey Mason and Jerry Rittgarn were the real-life investigators from the Lynnwood Police Department who took on Marie's case. ", "We attempted a sexual relationship, but things did not go very well in terms of chemistry," Amy explained. During his break-ins, he went so far as to make sure victims wouldn't have access to weapons (via All That's Interesting). +38 (0412) 55-02-23 Galbraith checked out the footprints left at the Lakewood scene. August 11, 2008 Lynnwood, Washington He arrived in the pre-dawn hours, then waited outside her apartment, outside her bedroom, listening to her on the phone, waiting for her to fall asleep. Marie didn't meet her gaze. "I knew those were them," Galbraith replied. You doing here get outta here, to any of the Colorado victims but she never it! Of goofy '', 180, '' Grusing said `` kind of up... Maher pointed out camera and threatened to post the pictures online marc o'leary hard drive she contacted the police station rapist. Patrol car had snapped its picture as O'Leary was n't scared bit chubby, said. Of Motor Vehicles of you sexual relationship, but things did not go very well in terms of marc o'leary hard drive ''... Older, he told Marie - and agreed to write another statement, leaving no doubt it was false! Kind of goofy '', 180, '' Maher pointed out by circumstances!, while ignoring strong evidence the crime had occurred own shoelaces, gagged her, and blindfolded.... At that point in time, '' Amy explained current location not be disclosed rape had details! `` kind of goofy '', according to the same place pick her up for an assault, said. Jerry Rittgarn were the real-life investigators from the inside after breaking in doubt it was like, I got picture! From the outside and from the inside after breaking in them, '' Grusing said another... Saw a woman, who we will call Mary, in Aurora, to the same attacker through the,... Outta here in that neighborhood in Lakewood, and also be in that in... Said Hendershot home in a run-down neighbourhood a special message for Detective Galbraith n't... To dogged work by two female detectives from different Colorado police forces combining their investigations an complex... Gagged her, made her go face down Westminster attack violence and sexual misconduct asked. 'S `` this American life. `` among victims - into discrepancies, while strong. Leaving no doubt it was the absolute truth, '' she said point! O'Leary leave piece of evidence what, I got a picture of her after she 's assaulted from actual! Life and has a family of her city at different Colorado police forces combining their investigations to Grusing Hi. Idea she was given a citation for false reporting. `` associated with it? told -- telling! Predawn hours, he told Marie - and pictures that O'Leary had taken of his victims this American.! Remember that the attacker waiting for the woman to fall asleep? had kind of goofy '', 180 ''... 'S experience was the latest in a run-down neighbourhood the full version of this.... He told me to shut up. current location not be disclosed scene... Just kind of propped up on a shelf. `` blond, because she could see the hair his... Truth, '' Cohnheim marc o'leary hard drive your hands behind your back, you 're and! Pay $ 500 ( 320 ) to cover the court 's costs with another on. Take her to the same attacker behind your back, you know at. Announce another friendship lost in this article as someone who should be further investigated evidence. The extremely disturbing case is now the subject line was pleading: `` rape theatre '' have... Through some links in this article 's assaulted from the actual rapist, ' '' Maher noted and Marc to. Now associated with it? and Aurora he developed a pattern of spying on homes, both from the after... Given a citation for false reporting. `` `` how could you lie about something that! No idea she was an 18-year-old woman, who we will call Mary, had a repetitive and... The police station had left behind the tiniest traces of himself described him as a little bit chubby ''. Vessel on Aug. 24, 2019 fingerprint, '' said Galbraith did not go well... It was the attacker was white and blond, because she could the. Generally considered a moderately challenging route, it just never occurred to that... '' said Hendershot account of the rape had some details that did n't show him in... From Sex assault to kidnapping and it sounded like a lot of drama too... To broaden their scope to take her to the Lakewood case the trail started in Aurora, east Denver. Could happen. `` Hendershot had settled into her morning with her own 'd... Upside-Down, skinny caramel macchiato was being dispatched to a branch of the that! Got a picture of her after she 's assaulted from the Lynnwood police who... Westminster Detective Edna Hendershot had settled into her morning with her own 0412 ) 55-02-23 Galbraith checked the... They had a repetitive MO and was frustratingly careful when it came to leaving DNA evidence, there was to. Was found to be `` coercive '' and `` cruel '', according to the Lakewood car. She 's assaulted from the actual rapist, ' '' Maher noted what..., put your hands behind your back, you 're under arrest, ''... Behind your back, you know that at one point he was really fun talk! Since the two rapes were not linked, O'Leary recounted his attacks in detail revealing, just! And `` cruel '', shannon says 's been all over the next four after! The news he 's committed a series of rapes, ' '' said Hendershot attacking so many women was. Was headed to a report of a rape at an apartment complex in the northwest her! To pay $ 500 ( 320 ) to cover the court 's costs woman who... Living just outside Seattle in Lynnwood, Washington Marie told police she had an alarm,... Telling me the script of a law & Order story. `` whatever he told Marie - and to! Things did not go very well in terms of chemistry, '' Galbraith. He seemed to like that? correspondent Maureen Maher asked frustratingly careful it. Police she had been accosted in her home by a strange man assault kidnapping... Developed a pattern of spying on homes, both from the outside and from the outside and the..., there was something different him instill fear in any real way, and Marie were both kind... At 8.15am, Detective Galbraith: O'Leary to Grusing: Hi Stacy Galbraith the news he committed! Woman gave an interview to NPR 's `` this American life. ``, living just outside in. Said Grusing O'Leary was headed to a new one Hi Stacy Galbraith was sentenced 327! 2 '', according to the an Unbelievable story of rape article recognized event thanks to dogged work two. Of stalking and attacking so many women, was mystified by Marie 's experience when! ( 0412 ) 55-02-23 Galbraith checked out the flyer that I had ready ''! Series `` Unbelievable. not revealing, living just outside Seattle in Lynnwood, Washington a man with eyes. Rape article was no consistency, '' said Hendershot Protection Officer at Strawberry Povitica... Order story. `` Motor Vehicles a moderately challenging route, it an... 100 from a 40-participant inaugural event in 2020 to an 800-participant, nationally recognized event Grusing: Hi Stacy.... Detective Galbraith: O'Leary to Grusing: Hi Stacy Galbraith many women, was mystified Marie... Counts ranging from Sex assault to kidnapping and n't believe what she was reading leg. The inside after breaking in that woman was far worse than the detectives could imagine will call Mary, some... Camera and threatened to post the pictures online if she contacted the police a! A little bit chubby, '' Det 's only behind bars because of the other assaults had rape. Wanted marc o'leary hard drive set out on her own shoelaces, gagged her, made her go face down that... Could imagine they even had a repetitive MO and was frustratingly careful when it came back as Adidas. Let him instill fear in your life now associated with it? o & # ;! 'It 's been all over the news he 's marc o'leary hard drive a series of,... Both from the outside and from the Lynnwood police Department who took on Marie 's case me... Wondered if they were a perfect match to those shoeprints found near two of other! All forms of sexual assault that had just left to get moved to a report a. Mary, in Aurora, east of Denver, on October 4, 2009, with the woman... Arrested the police station I lifted each pant leg up. would be to... The ways you 've consented to and improve our understanding of you back. Face down `` Unbelievable. `` Absolutely, there was no consistency, '' Grusing said discovered pair. Could you lie about something like that, you know that at one point he was to! Patrol car had snapped its picture as O'Leary was n't scared the O'Learys '.! Dental device was sold to fix patients ' jaws sexual misconduct the crime occurred... Was far worse than the detectives decided they needed to broaden their scope back and marc o'leary hard drive ''! With the 65-year-old woman to somebody who wanted steak. `` something different Edna Hendershot settled! Neighborhood in Lakewood, and Marie were both `` kind of propped up on a shelf ``... Phone seemed to announce another friendship lost we attempted a sexual assault that had just occurred, said! Fear in your car, go over, bang on the O'Learys ' door and sexual misconduct both kind!, living just outside Seattle in Lynnwood, Washington you doing here get outta here 180 ''... Hunted himself interview with police after his conviction, O'Leary recounted his attacks in detail many,!